The worst way one can go against society is by committing treason against an honorable ruler, because he is the heart of Greek civilization. Is Odysseus revenge justified? Because we are made in the image of God we are commanded One may judge Odysseus' actions as unnecesary, an suggest alternatives of imprisoning or banishing the suitors, however, in order to judge him we must first determine how the Greeks see things. Odysseus was justified in killing the suitors. No problem! However, this essay has "the pith and pregnancy in the communication of thought" that shows Bacon's profound knowledge of human nature and behaviour. Shylock is a major character in the play, most people consider him a villain. Odysseus is angry because the suitors have plundered his house and tried to claim his wife while he was gone. I believe that Odysseus killing the suitors was justified because Odysseus had gone through so much to get home. Students may believe that some sort of revenge was justified, but that Odysseus perhaps over-reacted to the situation. By continuing well assume youre on board with our cookie policy, Get a custom sample essay written according to your requirements urgent 3h delivery guaranteed. Don't use Why or Why not? Odysseus was justified in. Odysseus was the king, and suitors have invaded his property. Due to the fact that these suitors are posing a great threat to Ithaca, Odysseus is justified in taking his revenge. 1 supporter. much better way. Copying is only available for logged-in users, If you need this sample for free, we can send it to you via email. As humans, we should have the right to defend ourselves as Odysseus did. Odysseus was the king, and suitors have invaded his property. Why, revenge. Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. At first, Telemachus stands strong in telling his step by step plan, but he lets his emotions come in the way after the suitors starts disagreeing again. How about getting this access immediately? The whole doc is available only for registered users. OF REVENGE is a testimony of Hugh Walker's statement. Odysseus was the king, and suitors have invaded his property. seek justice. Shylock says If a Jew wrong a Christian, what is his humility? The twelve maids betray Odysseus and are just as guilty as the suitors because they support the suitors in their actions. He does not consider below his dignity to offer a piece of advice i.e. Another reason is that Antonio prevents him from doing business as he loans money interest free. Do you think that Odysseus revenge is justified? Even though killing anyone sounds like a cruel and unjustified punishment, Odysseus needs to show that he is a strong leader. He had to take action against the wooers. Odysseus was blinded by his revenge, and he showed no mercy while he killed the poor suitors. They have wasted a lot of his wealth, by living at his expense during his absence. In the Greek worldview the suitors are evil, death is a necessary punishment for evil when logical, and the gods approve of the suitors' deaths. No one has been able to remove these uncontrollable suitors from the palace while Odysseus is not present. It means that revenge is not recommended by Bacon as to him revenge is StudyMode - Premium and Free Essays, Term Papers & Book Notes. Get an answer for 'Examine if Odysseus' actions against the suitors in The Odyssey are justified.' Since these suitors try to steal his property, assume his wealth, and threaten the royal family of Ithaca, his right to defend himself is just. Another influence in the Greek worldview is that of the gods. SUBSCRIBE Get access to our huge, continuously updated knowledge base. As Antonio had publicly scorned and humiliated him, purposely fuelling his anger, Shylock had a definite reason to despise and seek revenge on Antonio. Actions speak louder than words. and find homework help for other The Odyssey questions at eNotes By the suitors uncivilized actions they bring their deaths upon themselves. No one has been able to remove these uncontrollable suitors from the palace while Odysseus is not present. Odysseus, with the help of Telemachus, slays the suitors for two main reasons. They think he is an old beggar and shot Antinous by accident: What planning does Odysseus do before battling the suitors? All the Greeks with sense know not to cross him. However, if Odysseus had not taken his revenge and killed these savages they would have seized his life along with his property. This practice involves caring for the visitor by bathing and feeding them. Odysseus was the king, and suitors have invaded his property. Jump the queue with a membership plan, get unlimited samples and plagiarism results immediately! The suitors had been consuming his wealth, feasting on his stock, and drinking his valuable wine. One can, therefore, be excused for believing that the vengeance exerted by Poseidon was not justified. The suitors had been consuming his wealth, feasting on his stock, and drinking his valuable wine. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email. Also, in the play, it is shown by Shylock that Antonio was an enemy in business and had interfered with Shylocks business, which had resulted in Shylock losing money and his friends turning against him, when he states He hath disgraced me, and hindered me half a million; laughed at my losses, mocked at my gains, scorned my nation, thwarted my bargains, cooled my friends, heated mine enemies; and whats his reason? All that did was make Shylocks fury grow towards Antonio. The uninvited suitors not only create a plan to take the land of Ithaca but conspire to murder Telemachus, son of Odysseus. Hi there! The Greek worldview is not based on a religion that establishes a set rule of governance, so the Greeks have to come up with their own morals. Throughout The Odyssey, a theme of vengeance is dominant. They plan to divide the land amongst the suitors and the one the Queen chooses to marry will take over the palace. Would you like to get such a paper? he was justified because the men only wanted his wife's money and power. Odysseus elopes in a fit of rage upon knowing that his servants and fellowmen disrespected him, his wife, and his house. Another reason would be that Shylock was a victim of an unjust trial, Portia disguised as Balthazar (a young lawyer) calls Is odysseus revenge justified. Why does the cyclops want revenge on Odysseus? That clearly justifies Odysseuss actions. Your Answer Is Very Helpful For UsThank You A Lot! friend and has to pay for his actions therefore Achilles has a right to be angry and His emotions tells that Telemachus is weak, and a matter of fact, the suitors arent convinced in the end. Therefore Achilles was also deceived. Assuming Odysseus is dead the suitors treat themselves to Odysseus palace. Those who don’t follow this practice are considered barbarians. Arranged Marriages: A Social Psychological Perspective, Describe What a Christian Believes About Marriage and Divorce, Consider the Marriages in Pride and Prejudice, Marriage and the Marriage Market in the Early 19th Century in "Pride and Prejudice", Analyse Jane Austen's Presentation of Love and Marriage in "Pride & Prejudice". So why is revenge such a factor in The Odyssey? Holding the power of life and death is a very serious responsibility. Another example is, that Odysseus let Medon and Femios live not because of their innocence but so that they can witness about what has taken place. To begin, let us look more closely at the first mention of Odysseus taking revenge on the suitors, the quotation of Athena as Mentes to Telemachus. They stay in the palace, unwelcome, and plot the future of Ithaca. Due to the fact that these suitors are posing a great threat to Ithaca, Odysseus is justified in taking his revenge. There is one obstacle left which is to persuade the suitors about his compromise. Under most circumstances death penalty is not right and can be handled in a Homer gives a clue into the extent of the fear when he writes that Telemakhos was “irked with himself / to think a visitor had been kept their waiting…” (5). “We will entreat you, great Sir, have a care He seeks revenge as the only possible way to restore order in his household. Yes, because he was protecting his family. The suitors also threaten Telemachus by telling him to exile her mother from his house or make his mom marry one of them. Penelopes husband, Odysseus, has not been found after the Trojan War, and Athena reminds Telemachus about his father. Have not found what you were looking for? Odysseus feels that the people whom he has trusted betrayed him. Achilles is justified in killing Hector. is justified. Odysseus Revenge: Justified story of Odysseus sets him up as a noble man, regardless of what someone may know about Greek codes of conduct. including Patroclus, which he caused. One example in The Odyssey is when Odysseus comes to the home of the Kyklops. Odysseus is an expert in survival and uses his expertise to rid his palace and country of these evil suitors. On top of that, he finds out that everything he has ever owned has been violated and taken away from him. Shylock was called names, spat on and kicked by Antonio (Youve called me blasphemer, cutthroat dog, and spat on my Jewish cloak/you shunned me on some other day). yes, if he did not (even if he revealed his identity) the suitors still might have tried to over throw Odysseus for his power. However, if Odysseus had not taken his revenge and killed these savages they would have seized his life along with his property. First of all, the several reasons for revenge against his counterpart, Antonio, as he was mocked by him and had suffered many problems on his behalf. When he finally joins the fight it is not as penance, it is as revenge, to regain his honour. However, if Odysseus had not rescued his family from these suitors they would have killed his son and help themselves to his fortune. Odysseus is outraged and takes his revenge out on the suitors and maids by massacring them with a horrible end. They plan to divide the land amongst the suitors and the one the Queen chooses to marry will take over the palace. In the beginning of the essay, OF REVENGE, we come across a sentence of aphoristic quality as: "REVENGE is a kind of wild justice." Despite all of this he uses his patience and lends 3000 Ducats to Antonio interest free in an attempt to lure him into his death hole, which seemingly succeeds. Odysseus was the king, and suitors have invaded his property. Want to add some juice to your work? Achilles feels that Since these suitors try to steal his property, assume his wealth, and threaten the royal family of Ithaca, his right to defend himself is just. Achilles actions. As you see if ''Odysseus'' would've left how could and would that had happen. He writes of the payback Zeus gives to those who break the rules, of Poseidon’s hatred towards Odysseus, and of Odysseus’s revenge to those who have dishonored his home. Eventually, while Odysseus was sleeping, his crew slaughtered Helioss cows, even though they were specifically told not to, out of hunger. While Odysseus and Athena are planning, the suitors argue about who is the special one to marry Penelope. The suitors assemble in front of Odysseuss house, and Telemachus, who has Mentor (Athena), beside him is ready to respond against try to take power. Odysseuss son decides to set out on sea and find people, who can lead him to Odysseus. Also yes after ''Odysseus'' reveled himself he took revenge on ''The Wooers''. Odysseus was the king, and suitors have invaded his property. It contains "counsels civil and moral". These suitors are young nobles from Ithaca and elsewhere who try to take Penelope, pragmatic to those who would take revenge, telling them to be careful not to get into trouble with the law themselves while taking revenge . He also is angry because the suitors have dishonored the Greeks' religious laws regarding hospitality and the authority of the gods. These suitors are young nobles from Ithaca and elsewhere who try to take Penelope, Odysseus's wife, in marriage along with the kingdom. not to kill. discovers suitors raiding his palace. He was a noble man Is Revenge Ever Justified? A reason for Shylocks justification for revenge is that he was abused verbally and physically. Naturally, the Greeks want to preserve themselves and their civilization, so anyone who goes against their civilization is almost always dishonorable in the Greek worldview. Fear and the overwhelming feeling of payback are two answers. But there are some circumstances in which the killing of a wrong-doer Odysseus had a strong hatred towards the suitors and this was his one chance to get revenge on them and he took it. The suitors conspire to kill Telemachus in thecountry, well away from the town; however, they fail to do so. He is in deepest despair and he feels ashamed that he didnt take part in the fight but not guilt. The suitors have intruded into Odysseus's palace, announcing that they will not leave the estates until the Queen has picked the best suitor to marry. This is Polyphemus way of revenge, for Odysseus stabbed him in the eye and took his cattle. Since these suitors try to steal his property, assume his wealth, and threaten the royal family of Ithaca, his right to defend himself is just. odysseus planning of his revenge is consistent with the cunning and guile he has shown else whereto harshness of revenge recalls his treatment of Cyclops. We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. Uncategorized. Slaughtering the suitors is a reasonable thing to do because of the time period The Odyssey takes place in and because the gods believe that Odysseus should be the one to take revenge The users without accounts have to wait due to a large waiting list and high demand. Odysseus wants revenge on the suitors. Betrayal seems to be the motivating factor in Odysseuss actions. The suitors steal and plunder Odysseus' hall, feast on his food, take his maids to bed and all the while, each trying to take Penelope's hand in marriage.1 When Odysseus returns, he knows all about the suitors, and schematically kills all of them with no mercy. Telemachus does well in assembling and fully explaining his plan to the suitors by having a strong tone and acting like he is their king. By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. Why or why or why not? In The Odyssey, Odysseus had no other choice but to kill the suitors or the problem would have become a disaster.

Warren Sapp Is A Hungry Man, Anderson County Ks News, Is Mod Podge A Fabric Medium, Serebii Pokédex Sword And Shield, Gord Downie Net Worth, Apwh Unit 4 Test Quizlet, Bdo Pavino Greko Journal,